Silver Bonus For All Seniors Or All Needy?

9 September 2014

In her article "Celebrate Old Age With 'Silver Bonus'" (The Straits Times, 27 Aug 2014), Kanwaljit Soin makes a plea for members of the Pioneer Generation to be given a "Silver Bonus".

She writes:

"There are just about 400,000 of us in Singapore — those aged 65 and older. About 35,000 of us earn less than $1,000 a month."

Just earlier this year, the Government said there were 450,000 members of the Pioneer Generation. How did Ms Soin conclude that the number had dwindled to 400,000 in a matter of months?

Also, Ms Soin claims that about 35,000 of the Pioneer Generation members earn less than $1,000 a month. But, are these 35,000 people actually working and earning less than $1,000 a month? Or, do they include those who are not working and therefore have no income from work (i.e., earn less than $1,000 a month).

Ms Soin concludes with her suggestion:

"If each one of us over 65 who is a resident in Singapore is given an old age allowance of just $200, it would be a good bonus.

...

The cost to the country would be $960 million annually.

The total cost of the Pioneer Package is $9 billion and this old age allowance could be a small part of the total package."

Unfortunately, Ms Soin ignores the fact that the $9 billion Pioneer Generation Package has already been earmarked for future medical expenses. There's nothing left for other purposes.

It will be more sensible to provide financial assistance to the needy.

No comments:

Post a Comment